| Indian Journal of Medical Ethics | ||||||
![]() Home Current Issue Past Issues Support About IJME Apr-Jun1997-5(2) |
Reproductive health care for women: a saga of excess,
exploitation and violation S. G. Kabra Introduction Documented malpractice and possible cures I. Unsafe methods of abortion vis-a-vis the Medical Termination
of Pregnancy (MTP) Act. As a result, unsafe abortions today constitute the single largest cause of pregnancy- related deaths. This is because the safety provisions of the MTP Act are not implemented by the health authorities. Whilst this may be just another example of the ubiquitous lack of monitoring by concerned authorities, a more sinister explanation could be a deliberate ‘blind eye’ to achieve population control through MTP. The safety provisions in the MTP Act require approval and monitoring of a MTP centre to ensure required surgical facilities and approval of the doctor’s qualification, competence and training. Abortion after 12 weeks of pregnancy is allowed only after consultation with two doctors and abortion is prohibited after the 20th week of pregnancy. Remedy: Ensuring facilities for safe abortion by strict implementation of the provisions of the MTP Act and by taking legal action against health authorities who fail to do so. II. Unsafe contraceptives Laparoscopic fallopian tube ligations are carried out improperly. This is due to compromise of mandatory surgical norms by using unsterile laparoscopes or by using unsafe procedures in place of those prescribed e. g. peritoneal insufflation with atmospheric air in place of carbon dioxide. At times, a cycle pump has been used for insufflation. As anticipated, the procedure fails and is attended by an increased rate of complications as the result of these unhygienic and unsafe practices. These lead to a high incidence of ectopic pregnancy and catastrophic illness with high mortality even where surgical facilities are available. The situation is worse in a rural setting. The estimated number of such deaths due to faulty tubectomies is 500 for the 5 million ligations presently done per year. The use of contraceptive pills without prior tests to ensure normal liver function constitutes a much greater hazard in our population as there is a high prevalence of liver diseases such as viral hepatitis (3% of our population is in the carrier stage of hepatitis- B while hepatitis- E is endemic) and amoebic hepatitis is common in our country. Other factors such as compromised liver function due to malnutrition, toxic damage from anti- tubercular drugs, consumption of aflatoxin from ill preserved food grains, toxic pesticide residues in food and water, and alcohol consumption increase the likelihood of liver disease in our population. Remedy:Peers in the profession practising ethical medicine, especially those practicing obstetrics and gynaecology, should invoke and insist upon exact adherence to medical ethics framed under the Medical Council of India (MCI) Act. III Prescription of unsafe drugs in pregnancy Remedy:Establishment of Drug Information Centres to educate doctors and patients on the safety status of drugs in pregnancy. IV Pesticide residues in food Remedy:Awareness and education programmes with stricter implementation of the Insecticide Act. V Aggressive advertisement of drugs and self-
medication Remedy: Insistence on implementation of the provisions of the Drugs and Magic Remedies (Objectionable) Advertisement Act that prohibits such advertisements. The offence is cognisable and the editor, publisher and advertiser are all individually and collectively liable. Action may also be initiated under the Press Council Act. VI Advertisement of abortion Unsafe abortions with their attendant miseries and deaths are on the rise as a result of this policy and exceed those in the pre- legalisation days. VII Surgical excesses on women apropos pregnancy
Remedy: The Medical Council Act provides protection against unnecessary surgical interventions. This should be invoked to penalise wrong- doers. VIII Experiments on women and methods of abortion for
contraceptive methods IX Unregulated, assisted pregnancy Remedy:Assisted reproduction should be strictly monitored, supervised and controlled. It should be cost-effective and subsidised as part of the family planning programme. X Gender bias in availability of health care
facilities S. G. Kabra, D-102, SDM Hospital, Jaipur 302 015 Fee- splitting or dichotomy in any shape or form is always unethical. It means obtaining money from a patient without disclosing in the bill that is submitted, the manner in which it is made up. Should the patient come to know of the underhand manner in which the doctor has split the fee he received for professional service, with a practitioner who brought the patient to him, the patient can institute legal proceedings against the doctor. The offence is punishable in law. -Dr. Rustom N. Cooper
|
|||||
|
| ||||||