| Indian Journal of Medical Ethics | ||||||
![]() Home Current Issue Past Issues Support About IJME Oct-Dec2003-11(4) |
BOOK REVIEW Mind, heart and
medicine Kaustubh
Gokhale Bernard Lown.The lost art of healing: practising compassion in medicine. New York:Ballantine Books, 1999. US$ 14, pp 332.
ISBN 0-345425979 Bernard Lown is a pioneer in research on sudden cardiac death. He invented
the defibrillator and introduced the technique of cardioversion. He discovered
the use of lidocaine in treating ventricular arrhythmias. Very early in the
course of his career Dr Lown shed light on the relationship between potassium
and digitalis. For his exceptional work in raising public awareness of the
catastrophic consequences of nuclear war, he was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize
in 1985. This distinguished cardiologist, whose research and wisdom have shaped
modern cardiology, writes his memoirs and also pinpoints the ills plaguing
modern medicine and suggests a cure. The first section of the book, entitled 'Hearing the patient: the art of
diagnosis', uses anecdotes and human interest stories to illustrate how arriving
at a clinical diagnosis is a creative and satisfying experience. He states that
the science of history taking, the art of listening and the insights obtained by
touching are interwoven to produce truth. At a time when medicine is becoming
increasingly entangled in a love affair with technology, this is a bold and
courageous statement in favour of clinical acumen and bedside skills. The chapter on 'Mind and heart' makes for fascinating reading while 'Killed
by the imagination' is a chilling account of the power of mind over matter. Dr
Lown's preoccupation with psychology and his concerns regarding the role of
psychological factors and stress in causing sudden cardiac death are evident. He
devotes an entire chapter to Munchausen syndrome, an entity that is consistently
chastening and disconcerting to physicians and shows how little the medical
profession understands the human mind. A section devoted to the disappearing art of doctoring explores the
doctor-patient relationship. His views regarding the power of words are
thought-provoking. Wrong words can maim as easily as a physical assault; yet
words also have a far greater potential for healing. He writes about scientific
discoveries and inventions that have changed the face of modern cardiology. The
chapters on digitalis, the discovery of the defibrillator and the genesis of
coronary care units transport us into the past. We experience the thrill of
reading the history of modern cardiology being made, with Dr Lown as the chief
protagonist. These stories leave one in awe of this brilliant scientist who by
the sheer magnitude of his contributions seems to have single-handedly elevated
the field of cardiology to its current position. Yet, he remains remarkably down-to-earth, self-critical and insightful, as
his concluding lines on coronary care units proves. He writes: 'Of course every silver lining has its cloud. Every advance exacts a cost.
Medicine grew even more depersonalised. Technology took precedent and patients
became secondary (with the advent of CCU). A paradox of my life and its ultimate
irony is that my research work facilitated that which I utterly deplore.' Dr Lown writes compassionately about the challenges in caring for the
elderly. No pills, just sensitivity, innovation and imagination are his mantras
in dealing with the problems faced by the elderly. His essay on death and dying
reveals a deep understanding of the uncertainties and frailties of life. He is
disturbed by the schizophrenic mix of denial and morbid preoccupation that
humans have regarding death. Dr Lown calls for the 'deinsti-tutionalisation' of
death. He believes that lending 'dignity to death' will remain just a distant
dream unless hospitals are decoupled from the act of dying. The book is peppered with fond memories of his mentor, Dr Samuel A Levine.
Their mutual respect, their disagreements and skirmishes add an element of drama
to the narrative. It is an immensely readable and thought-provoking book which
is a treasure trove of wisdom, advice and knowledge for all those aspiring to be
doctors in the true sense. KAUSTUBH GOKHALE, Lecturer, Department of Medicine, Mahatma Gandhi Institute of Medical Sciences, Sevagram, Maharashtra. India. e-mail:kauswatg@yahoo.com |
|||||
|
| ||||||