Home
Current Issue
Past Issues
Support
About IJME
Oct-Dec2003-11(4)
INSPIRING LIVES
'In matters of money and
murder, it is the first step that is difficult.'
Hemantha
Senanayake
Professor A H
Sheriffdeen,FRCS, retired recently after a distinguished
career as professor of surgery at the University of Colombo, Sri Lanka. He will
be remembered for his uncompromising standards, dedication to work and
pioneering spirit. He used his considerable influence in society to raise funds
to improve the standards of health care.Hemantha Senanayake [HS] spoke to
him.
HS: Sir, I have known you for more than 25
years and in all this time I have never known your integrity to be challenged.
Where do you draw the inner strength for practising ethically? Is it religious,
moral, or an inspiring role model?
AHS: I don't think I have a particular role model
whose lifestyle I have emulated, on whose life I have based mine. I am a
religious person but I am not strongly religious. I have always wanted to
practise with a code of conduct that, for instance, my parents, my school and my
teachers will be proud of. That has been the formula that has guided my life. I
have asked myself, 'Will they will be proud of what I am doing?' If so, I'd go
ahead and do it. If I thought they would object to something then I would have
probably desisted.
HS: Would you like to mention anybody in
particular?
AHS: Well, I must mention one of my school
principals Reverend Father Rosati.
HS: And what was his influence on
you?
AHS: As a child I attended St Andrew's College,
Nawalapitiya. A teacher there advised my father to move me to St Anthony's
College, Kandy, because of its reputation. I sat for an entrance exam and when
my father and I went to meet Revd Fr Rosati, we were shown that I had scored a
zero in mathematics! He said to my father, 'I have read his English essay and I
think there is a lot of potential in this child. I am going to give him a
chance.' That particular statement stuck in my mind. In response I said to
myself, 'I will never ever let down anybody who has placed his or her trust in
me.' This is something that has stayed with me through my whole life. Fr Rosati
died of a heart attack two years later. For me, it was a great tragedy, because
I never came under his influence. I must have been about ten years old at the
time and he taught a higher class. I always held him in high
esteem.
HS: What do you see as the high points in your
career?
AHS: Well, most professional people will look at
high points of a career in terms of their academic achievements, such as MBBS or
FRCS. To me, these were never high points. I can think of a few important
events, such as my appointment as the professor of surgery. Not that I think of
it as a high point as such, but because I hold a different perspective on such
things. I was the chairman, board of studies for postgraduates, which again is
the highest office one can hold. I have also received decorations which I shy
away from; awards which I have been coerced into taking. Among those, are some
national awards that were given by politicians. I have been pressurised into
accepting a few after being 'warned' of the consequences of refusing awards by
the highest authorities in the land! But, on a more serious note, two of the
highlights of my career have been the introduction of vascular surgery to Sri
Lanka and the establishment of the renal transplantation programme.
We have trained several vascular surgeons and it
has become an established specialty today. Then, the renal transplantation
programme: we initiated this with Professor Rezvi Sheriff, Professor Geri
Jayasekera and many other doctors. Without their support, this wouldn't have
been a reality. So the renal transplantation programme was not my effort alone.
In fact, I constantly keep telling people not to refer to it like that. I played
a catalyst's role and put a unit together: That's all I did.
HS: Would you like to share some angles on what
can be considered ethical and what is considered unethical in practice?
AHS: With respect to transplantation, there are
various ethical dilemmas that we are confronted with. One is the economic
dilemma, the ethics of resource allocation. People have come up to me and asked,
'Do you feel comfortable spending so much resources just to save one life in a
poor country such as Sri Lanka, especially when that money could be used to save
many other lives?' And that has been a battle. But in response I have asked, 'If
you had to watch your brother or your sister struggling for life, then, would
you consider it too great a cost?' In fact, I have seen this very thing
happening. Someone once gave a public lecture against transplantation. At the
end of the lecture he said, 'There is a surgeon at the end of the hall who will
be able to answer most of the questions I have raised.' In reply, I asked the
question I mentioned earlier. Many years later, he brought his own cousin for
renal transplantation, forgetting that he had questioned me in public about the
moral dilemma.
There is another ethical dilemma which always comes
up-about the non-related donor. Non-related transplantation is an immense
problem, with some trying to influence a person to sacrifice a kidney by
offering a lot of money. Today we use only related donors. I didn't want the
situation where gangs tout for poor people's kidneys as in some other
countries.
HS: How do you manage not to compromise on your
ethics?
AHS: I firmly believe in that well-known saying:
'In matters of money and murder, it is the first step that is difficult.' From
that point onwards one can take bribes or even go on to murder or commit
whatever crime with very little remorse, not letting it affect one's conscience.
Similarly, in ethical dilemmas, if you stop yourself from taking that very first
step and you do not compromise, you will find that you will always stand firm.
You will not lower your standards if you don't take that first step.
HS: How do you cope when you see less talented
competitors getting ahead of you using unethical means?
AHS: I know it's a difficult problem to deal with.
In the face of it if one doesn't lose one's own ethical standards and maintain
them, the day will come when the rest of your community will realise that here
is a person who is doing things the correct way. The truth will always surface.
I don't think that I have ever had a fear in that. I have seen this happen and I
get saddened by it but really, time will tell. It is the person who indulges in
it who will have to live with his conscience.
HS: What gives you a kick in this day and
age?
AHS: In today's world of course, there is a huge
information outlet where one can practise evidence-based surgery. That is one of
the key guiding factors for a good professional life. The technology developed
for diagnostic tools, and all types of technology are available today. What
gives me a kick or satisfaction is that in spite of all this, patients come to
me for a good clinical examination. I feel that if you develop the brain and
touch of the fingers no technology will ever replace you. You will then derive
immense satisfaction by beating the computers and beating the most modern
technology available for diagnostics.
HS: What advice do you have for young doctors?
AHS: I give a lecture to entrants to the university
on 'Commitment to patient care'. I tell them, 'If you, at the beginning of your
life, focus on patient care first, regardless of what happens, you can enjoy
life. At the same time you don't have to be a priest and devote your entire life
to only practising medicine or surgery at the expense of enjoying life. You must
hold your focus in the face of conflict-a conflict between patient care and
going for a party, for instance. You must strive to know, clearly, which the
right thing to do is.' The advice I give them is: 'Try to make up your mind
without letting doubts plague you. If you don't allow a conflict to arise within
you about what is correct, the rest will come automatically. If you are able to
do that, you have really achieved immense peace within.'
HEMANTHA SENANAYAKE, Senior lecturer in obstetrics
and gynaecology and secretary of the Ethical Review Committee at the Faculty of
Medicine, University of Colombo, Sri Lanka. e-mail: hsenan@sltne.lk