Home
Current Issue
Past Issues
Support
About IJME
Apr-Jun2004-12(2)
FILM REVIEW
Medicine-the best
laughter
Kishore
Shah
How do they depict a doctor in Hindi films or TV
serials? He is either a grave-faced, bespectacled, didactic person somberly
announcing that either the mother or the child will survive, but not both, or he
is a buffoon who is acted out by Johnny Lever, or some other comedian with
outlandish mannerisms and remedies.
In this respect,Munnabhai MBBScomes
across as a breath of fresh air. It is a comedy that does not laugh at doctors,
rather it laughs with doctors at the medical education system. The movie can be
viewed at different levels. At one level, it is a gut comedy in which a local
don pretends to be a doctor to please his father. When his trickery is exposed,
he vows to become a real doctor-more by crook than by hook! The acting by Sanjay
Dutt, as Munnabhai and Sunil Dutt is excellent. Arshad Warsi as 'Circuit', the
don's right hand, is superb. However, the surprise packet is Boman Irani, who
delights you with his understated role as Dean of the college and father of
Munnabhai's lady love.
As a doctor, I viewed this movie as a message for
the medical fraternity. Munnabhai gets admission into a prestigious college by
cheating in the exams. This would have been hilarious if it had not been true.
Unfortunately, our dailies scream about how various entrance tests are
manipulated, and how medical admission has become less of a competition and more
of an auction.
The scene where juniors are made to strip and dance
as a part of ragging are straight out of the newspapers. Munnabhai tries to view
the dissection from behind a large flock of students and suddenly I was
transported back to my student days, when we had to crane over heads to watch a
patient. Our colleges today are as over-crowded as ever. Munnabhai grabs a
mobile and orders his sidekick to get a separate and fresh body for himself. I
applauded the dark humour of this scene.
Part of the movie becomes unnecessarily heavy and
pedantic, when it advises doctors to treat patients as individuals and not as
diseases or a bunch of symptoms. Though this is perfectly true, it comes across
as a dreary speech. Just like Robin Williams, in Patch Adams, Munnabhai also
treats patients with a hug and a kiss, and a little bit of
understanding.
Munnabhai communicates with the sweeper by just
asking him his name. This scene made me pause and wonder if I knew the names of
all the ward boys and ayahs who helped run the hospitals where I work. I am sure
that I would be found sorely wanting.
The ease with which the Dean could make or break
Munnabhai's medical career chilled my heart. I recollected all the PG students
who scurried to the market to buy vegetables for their guides, just to remain in
their good books. Is it right, or rather, is it safe to give such power over
another person to anyone, even if he is a senior doctor? Should we not ensure an
influence-free exam, where only merit is evaluated?
There is one scene in the movie which is
outstanding. Boman Irani suffers from hypertension. He uses laughter therapy to
lower his blood pressure whenever he gets angry. Due to various
misunderstandings, Munnabhai tells him that he no longer loves Chinki, his
childhood sweetheart and Irani's daughter. Irani pretends to commiserate with
Munna, while secretly bubbling with joy. Then Munna explodes the bombshell. He
tells Irani that now he actually loves Dr Suman, the real name of Chinki
(Irani's daughter). The play of emotions on Irani's face is wonderful. For two
minutes, this man does not utter a single syllable, and yet he conveys his
futile attempt to laugh his hypertension away and his frustration at the irony
of fate. The whole audience rolls with laughter during this part. This one
sequence makes the whole movie worth watching.
When you leave the cinema hall, there is a smile on
your lips. Most of the movie is couched in Bollywood hyper-bole. However,
somewhere deep down, you realise that beneath the laughter lie so many
shortcomings of our medical education system, which Munnabhai subtly points out
to us.
KISHORE SHAH,Matru Seva Hospital, 407/5 Nana Peth,
Pune 411 002, India. e-mail:shah123@vsnl.net